In 1988, Billy Sansone opened Cafe Testarossa, combining his passion for great food and his love of cars—especially the iconic Ferrari Testarossa. With a focus on authentic Italian flavors and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, Billy set out to create more than just another Italian restaurant. He wanted a place where families and friends could gather over classic pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and freshly prepared specialties that reminded him of Sunday dinners growing up. Named after his favorite car, Cafe Testarossa quickly became a local favorite in Syosset for anyone looking to enjoy the true taste of Italy.
1999
1999
Weekend Favorite to Weeknight Romance
As the millennium approached in 1999, Cafe Testarossa proudly celebrated its 11th anniversary as a thriving Italian restaurant in the heart of Syosset. What started as Billy Sansone’s passion project had grown into a beloved local gem, known for its warm hospitality, signature pasta dishes, and a dining room that buzzed with conversation and clinking wine glasses. Over the years, word spread beyond the weekend rush—Testarossa had become just as popular for mid-week dinners, drawing couples in for quiet date nights over candlelight and Chianti. The kitchen stayed true to its roots, crafting every dish with care and tradition, while the dining room filled with regulars who felt more like family. Ten years in, it was clear—Cafe Testarossa wasn’t just a restaurant; it was part of the community.
2014
2014
Testarossa Takes the Stage
By 2014, the secret was out. After years as Syosset’s go-to spot for Italian food, Cafe Testarossa was featured in Newsday, bringing well-earned attention to its unique blend of modern Italian dining and timeless, authentic flavors. The article captured what regulars had long known — that Cafe Testarossa wasn’t just serving dinner, it was offering an experience. With sleek, updated interiors, creative seasonal specials, and classics like house-made pastas and pork chops done right, the restaurant began drawing food lovers from all over Long Island. What started as a passion project became a destination, where tradition met innovation — and every night was something special.
2024
2024
Long Island’s Best Italian Restaurant — Officially
In 2024, Cafe Testarossa was proudly named Best Italian Restaurant on Long Island by the prestigious Bethpage Best of LI Awards, a recognition that celebrates 35 years of exceptional food, service, and community connection. Located at 499 Jericho Turnpike in Syosset, Cafe Testarossa has become a destination for food lovers seeking the perfect blend of traditional Italian recipes and modern culinary creativity. From handmade pasta and signature veal dishes to bold, contemporary specials, every plate is a reflection of the restaurant’s passion for flavor and quality. Whether you’re a local or visiting from across Long Island, there’s a reason why Cafe Testarossa continues to lead the way in modern Italian cuisine. We look forward to you joining our family.
What hasn’t changed
Classic pasta, wood-fired pizza and freshly prepared specialties, the kind that remind you of Sunday dinner. Billy’s idea in 1988 is still the plan tonight.
We had a wonderful experience hosting a baby shower at Cafe Testarossa! From start to finish, everything was exceptional. Danielle was an absolute pleasure to work with. She was so sweet, organized, responsive, and helpful throughout the entire process. She always answered her phone and made everything feel seamless and stress-free. The food on the day of the event was outstanding, just as delicious as if you were dining there for a special dinner. The staff was attentive, professional, and always present to make sure everything ran smoothly. Cafe Testarossa is a fantastic venue for a special occasion, and we couldn't have been happier with our experience. Thank you to Danielle and the entire team for helping make such a memorable day so special. Highly recommend!
M
Maureen M
★★★★★
Amazing spot!!
M
Milena C
★★★★★
Omg , it was the best experience ever!!! Great steak , great drinks and great service. I highly recommend the restaurant….
T
Terri J
★★★★★
Great, Great Food. Had the octopus appetizer and had the black linguine entree. Food and service were Fabulous.
D
Dina G
★★★★★
The food was amazing,it was our first time in the restaurant and we will be back.Debiie is so so swee!! Great customer service.
M
Meizhi S
★★★★★
Great food! 食物很美味😋
R
Robert b
★★★★★
You’ll truly enjoy the food and service.
J
Jack L
★★★★★
Cafe Testarossa has been a favorite place of mine for many years. Aside from their welcoming and pretty hostesses, the food is always fresh, authentic, and delicious. I love that there is always a printout of specials tucked each day inside their menu. Whether posted up at the bar where they make outstanding drinks/cocktails or table side in their lovely dining room, the atmosphere at Cafe Testarossa is always wonderful. Five stars all around!
