Best Italian Restaurant Long Island

Awards & PressBest Italian

We’re thrilled to share that Cafe Testarossa has officially been named Best Italian Restaurant on Long Island in the 2024 Bethpage Best of LI Awards!

Located at 499 Jericho Turnpike in Syosset, Cafe Testarossa has been a beloved neighborhood favorite since first opening its doors in February 1988. For over three decades, we’ve been honored to serve our community with passion, consistency, and a genuine love for hospitality.

Meet the Owner

Behind the magic is our owner — a self-taught restaurateur whose dedication to the craft has never wavered. While our owner never attended formal culinary school, his passion for the hospitality industry and commitment to excellence have guided every decision since day one. His philosophy is simple:

"If you love something enough, you’ll work at learning and perfecting it."

Our owner’s drive to innovate while staying true to Italian tradition has shaped Testarossa’s signature style — a refined yet inviting dining experience, blending classic flavors with modern touches. From handcrafted pastas to inventive specials, every dish reflects the creativity and care our owner and his team bring to the table.

What truly sets Testarossa apart is the team behind it — both in the kitchen and on the floor. Our owner always says:

"You’re only as good as the people around you."

The Bethpage Best of LI Awards praised Cafe Testarossa as “the epitome of culinary excellence,” applauding our ability to “tantalize taste buds and delight diners with every bite.” We’re humbled by the recognition and incredibly grateful to everyone who voted and continues to support us.

Come Taste What Everyone’s Talking About

Our menu blends Italian tradition with modern touches — handmade pastas, inventive specials and a curated wine list. Make a reservation and join us.